SLABBYPREPSee a sample verdict · Subscribe · $3/month →

Preparing cards for grading

How PSA, CGC, TAG and ACE ask for cards to be sleeved, held and packed, in their own order and from their own pages. Each section links the pages its steps come from, with the date each was read. Beckett (BGS) and SGC block automated reading of their sites, so their instructions are not repeated here. Where a company’s page differs from this one, its page wins.

1. Before you sleeve: check the centering

Each company publishes centering lines, so centering is a grading criterion you can measure at home before you pay, and it is best measured with the card out of the sleeve: a penny sleeve blurs the border edge by a fraction of a millimetre, which is the whole margin near a line (how to check card centering). The SlabbyPrep app measures it from a photo, front and back, against each company’s published lines, and estimates whether grading pays after each company’s fee, from the prices you give it: $3/month. Corners, edges and surface are graded too, so a measurement is a check, not a grade.

2. Sleeve and holder, company by company

CompanySleeveHolderNot wantedSource
PSAClear penny sleeve, not solid or opaqueSemi-rigid, 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 in for standard cardsTop-loaders, tape, pull tabs, sticky notesShipping Guide, November 21, 2026
CGCA protective sleeveA semi-rigid sleeve sturdy enough for CGC to take the card out safelyNone listedShipping page, November 21, 2026
TAGA soft sleeveA 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 semi-rigid such as Card Saver I, requiredTop-loaders, one-touch magnetic cases, screw-down holders, Ultra-Pro Card Preservers; tape or stickers on the semi-rigid; a team bag around each cardHelp article, November 21, 2026
ACEA penny sleeveA semi-rigid card holder, one card per holder; a magnetic case advised for patch or thicker cardsElastic bands, tape on the holders, pull tabs on the sleevesPackaging article, November 21, 2026
BGS, SGCNot covered: their sites block automated readingbeckett.com and gosgc.com

3. Pack and ship, company by company

PSA

  1. Each card in a clear penny sleeve. PSA says solid or opaque sleeves cause delays.
  2. Each sleeved card in a semi-rigid holder, 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 inches for standard cards, both sides visible. No top-loaders, tape, pull tabs or sticky notes.
  3. The cards stacked in the exact order of the submission form, item 1 on top.
  4. The stack between two cardboard dividers with two or three rubber bands: tight enough to stop it shifting, loose enough not to damage the cards.
  5. The stack wrapped in packing material, in a new box, with the gaps filled.
  6. The printed submission form in the box; several submissions each bundled separately.
  7. Every seam sealed with packing tape, not painter’s tape, Scotch tape or reused tape.
  8. The tracking label ID from the confirmation page on the outside of the box, with its barcodes fully visible; PSA says skipping this can delay order entry.
  9. The shipping label stuck directly on the box, not in a label pouch, addressed to the right PSA location.

PSA’s Shipping Guide also lists PSA’s address for each carrier. PSA’s other steps, from choosing a tier to tracking the order: how to submit cards to PSA.

Read on November 21, 2026: PSA’s Shipping Guide.

CGC

  1. Each card in a protective sleeve, then in a semi-rigid sleeve sturdy enough for CGC to take the card out safely.
  2. All the cards between two pieces of cardboard larger than the cards, in the order they appear on the submission form’s packing slip.
  3. The cardboard held with rubber bands just tight enough to keep the pieces together and the cards from falling out; CGC says cards packed too tightly may be damaged.
  4. The bundle protected with packing material such as bubble wrap, in a sturdy cardboard box, not packed too tightly.
  5. The packing slip (or slips) in the box with the cards, then the outside of the box completely sealed with packing tape.
  6. For the WalkThrough tier, each side of the box marked WK in large, bold letters; for Express, EX; with several tiers in one box, the highest, fastest tier. CGC says wrongly marked packages are delayed. Its fee table adds UV for Unlimited Value.

CGC’s Shipping Cards to CGC page calls these instructions suggestions only: the customer alone is responsible for packing the cards safely. You are also responsible for getting them to CGC safely; the shipping you choose when you submit is for the return trip. CGC’s fee table says CGC does not return Mylars, backing boards, card savers, sleeves or other storage and shipping materials sent in with cards, and CGC’s submission FAQ counts whether a submission was packaged correctly among the things that can change its turnaround. The rest of CGC’s steps: how to submit cards to CGC.

Read on November 21, 2026: CGC’s Shipping Cards to CGC page, CGC’s fee table, CGC’s submission FAQ.

TAG

TAG’s guidance for cards mailed without its Submission Kit (TAG’s help article):

  1. Each card in a soft sleeve, then a semi-rigid card shield; TAG says 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 semi-rigids such as Card Saver I are required. No clear tape or stickers sealing the semi-rigids and no team bag around each card: TAG says these can delay processing.
  2. No top-loaders, one-touch magnetic cases, screw-down holders or Ultra-Pro Card Preservers. TAG says orders not sent in semi-rigid shields may be subject to processing delays and handling fees.
  3. The cards together between slightly larger pieces of cardboard, held with painter’s tape or rubber bands.
  4. Outer protection such as bubble wrap or shipping paper, in a cardboard box with the order documentation (the packing list from the submission email, or a copy of the order from the my.taggrading.com portal), the cards in the order your initial order lists them.
  5. New, undamaged packaging where possible: TAG says packages that arrive heavily worn, damaged or tampered with may be rejected and returned unopened.

TAG highly recommends filming the cards as you pack them, front and back of each card, the materials and the sealing of the box, because in a loss or damage dispute it is not generally able to accept raw “pre-grading” images. It recommends UPS, FedEx or DHL, which collect a signature on delivery (it cannot confirm receipt of USPS packages), and boxing the cards and insuring the shipment, as it is not responsible for damage to cards in transit. The article also asks for a marking on the outside of the box for some service levels; TAG’s pages described its service levels differently on November 20, 2026, so the markings are left out here: check the article for your order before you seal the box.

Read on November 21, 2026: TAG’s help article on mailing cards without the Submission Kit.

ACE

  1. Each card in a penny sleeve, then a semi-rigid card holder, one card per holder. ACE says it can guarantee that cards sent this way are not handled before grading, and that cards sent in any other holder are taken out and put into a penny sleeve and semi-rigid holder on arrival. For patch cards or thicker cards it advises a magnetic case.
  2. No elastic bands binding cards together (they can bend the cards), no tape shutting the holders (it can stick to the cards in transit) and no pull tabs on the sleeves (they can leave indents).
  3. The cards in the same order as on the submission slip, in a sturdy box that fits them easily, packed securely with packing paper or bubble wrap so nothing moves in transit.
  4. The printed submission slip in the box, and the submission number cut from the top of the slip and taped to the outside. ACE says a barcode not clearly on the outside of the box may delay the submission on arrival.
  5. Several submissions in one box: each wrapped separately with its own packing slip and submission number, and all their barcodes on the outside of the box, next to each other on one side. ACE says delays caused by wrong labelling are not accommodated.
  6. From inside the UK: the box taken to a post office, or collected by a courier you book, as ACE’s How to Submit page says for UK senders. ACE strongly advises a tracked delivery service and recommends Royal Mail Special Delivery.
  7. From outside the UK, the United States included: ACE accepts only parcels sent through its DHL Express integration. Print the DHL Express label from ACE’s website, fix it to the outside of the parcel and drop the parcel at a DHL Express service point, which ACE recommends doing within 5 days of confirming the submission; no customs forms are needed. ACE gives 31 × 24 × 17 cm as the largest box for international senders: a larger box is not eligible for its free inbound shipping option and carries a £20 penalty fee, converted to your local currency.

ACE says it is not responsible for the condition of cards on arrival and does not treat them as damaged unless the packaging arrives visibly damaged or tampered with; defects found at grading are deemed to have been on the card when it arrived (ACE’s card-handling article). It cannot return any packaging, penny sleeves, semi-rigid holders, top-loaders and magnetic cases included (ACE’s packaging article).

Steps 1 and 2 are from ACE’s packaging article; 3 and 4 from its How to Submit page and the packaging article; 5 from its article on several submissions in one parcel; 6 from the How to Submit page and the packaging article; 7 from its International Submitters page and the How to Submit page.

Read on November 21, 2026: ACE’s How to Submit page, ACE’s packaging article, ACE’s card-handling article, ACE’s article on several submissions in one parcel, ACE’s International Submitters page.

ACE’s other steps, from choosing a service level to paying at the end: how to submit cards to ACE.

Beckett (BGS) and SGC

Beckett’s and SGC’s sites block automated reading, so this page repeats none of their instructions. Read them on the companies’ own sites before you pack: beckett.com and gosgc.com.

Before you sleeve them: measure each card and get the verdict, $3/month →

Questions

Top-loader or semi-rigid holder for grading?

Semi-rigid, at every company whose pages are used here. PSA’s Shipping Guide (read November 21, 2026) asks for a semi-rigid holder, 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 inches for standard cards, and no top-loaders. TAG (read November 21, 2026) requires a 3 5/16 × 4 7/8 semi-rigid such as Card Saver I and asks for no top-loaders, one-touch magnetic cases or screw-down holders. CGC (read November 21, 2026) asks for a semi-rigid sleeve. ACE (read November 21, 2026) asks for a penny sleeve in a semi-rigid card holder, advises a magnetic case for patch or thicker cards, and moves cards that arrive in any other holder into a penny sleeve and semi-rigid holder. Beckett’s and SGC’s sites block automated reading, so they are not covered.

Should I tape the semi-rigid shut or add a pull tab?

No, at the three companies that say. PSA asks for no tape, pull tabs or sticky notes on the holder; TAG asks for no clear tape or stickers sealing the semi-rigids; ACE asks for no tape on the holders, which can stick to the cards in transit, and no pull tabs on the sleeves, which can leave indents. CGC’s shipping page does not say. (Read: PSA November 21, 2026, TAG November 21, 2026, ACE November 21, 2026.)

Do grading companies send the sleeves and holders back?

Not CGC or ACE. CGC’s fee table says it does not return Mylars, backing boards, card savers, sleeves or other storage and shipping materials sent in with cards; ACE says it cannot return any packaging, penny sleeves, semi-rigid holders, top-loaders and magnetic cases included (read: CGC November 21, 2026, ACE November 21, 2026). TAG’s article does not say, and the PSA steps used here do not cover it.

Should I check centering before or after sleeving the cards?

Before. Centering is best measured with the card out of the sleeve: a penny sleeve blurs the border edge by a fraction of a millimetre, which is the whole margin near a line. Measure by hand with the steps in SlabbyPrep’s guide to checking card centering, or from a photo with the SlabbyPrep app ($3/month).

How to submit to PSA · how to submit to CGC · how to submit to ACE · how to check centering · printable centering cheat sheet · cheapest grading right now